add to wish list | library

16 of 21 recommend this,
would you recommend it?

yes | no


Reviews: Mahler: Symphony No. 2 - Nott

join discussion

Reviews: 3
add review

Site review by Geohominid June 29, 2010
Performance:   Sonics:    
In the continuing avalanche of Mahler symphony recordings, Nott's cycle has apparently been treated as rather peripheral compared to discs by the so-called mainstream 'usual suspects'. But there has been critical acclaim from those who care to listen to a so-called provincial orchestra. The recent excellent Ninth (Mahler: Symphony No. 9 - Nott) is a case in point. Nott's interpretations aim at producing a Mahler's Mahler performance, rather than a conductor's self-regarding one. Without the usual histrionics or exaggerations, it seems to me that this is proving to be a revelatory and important cycle. And the developing rapport between Nott and his increasingly idiomatic and stylish Bamberg orchestra, allied to exemplary engineering, truly gives us Mahler discs to be reckoned with.

An important feature of this Resurrection Symphony for me is the feeling that all the performers really believe in the power of this music to inspire the human spirit. Without such dedication the symphony becomes an unruly and sprawling philosophical wallowing in those outdated tenets of Nietzsche and Klopstock which inspired the composer. Audiences of Mahler's day would, however, have been familiar with these then highly fashionable philosophical ideas about the meaning of Life, and thus had different 'ears' to ours. There is an honestly expressed dedication to this performance which makes it build ineluctably to a glorious and inevitable climax, which in this case really does give its all.

Nott's first movement, on the faster side along with Fischer rather than the more cautious MTT, paints a cohesive, urgent and turbulent landscape, darkened by the tragic grandeur of funeral marches. These traversals of the Soul's landscape intersect nostalgic cameos of the Austrian countryside in vivid sound-painting. Nott's canvas is beautifully and realistically limned by superb engineering, within the potent atmosphere of a great auditorium during live performances. We are placed in the best seats, with the huge orchestra (including quadruple wind and five clarinets, clearly laid out before us. I could detect only one brief contribution from the audience, a discreet cough from a lady (the recording is that good), and there is no applause. How on earth, after the finale, the audience managed to let the final E flat chord die away in ambience for several seconds without bursting into acclaim, I would love to know.

The dramatic and wilful outbursts of the first movement are tempered by an unusually gentle Ländler, played with extreme elegance and delicate poise; there are lovely string swoops and unusual refinement from the strings and wind. This makes the following Scherzo all the more subversive and eruptive, based on the ironic spinning tune from Mahler's Songs of a Wayfarer which depicts St Anthony's sermon to the fish - droll, even sinister. This often amusing satire is sharply underlined by Nott's dual Trios, full of gemütlichkeit ('cosiness') and gilded with deliciously schmaltzy trumpet solos. The impressive climax before the end is one of those where Mahler seems to have briefly opened the gates of Heaven - another such occurs in the slow movement of the Fourth Symphony, also based on Wayfarer songs.

With the scene now set, the business of realising the philosophical core of this work begins. The lovely song "Urlicht", tenderly intoned by contralto Lioba Braun from an atmospheric position seemingly within the orchestra, is pure balm. Her rich voice and depth of feeling gives her the qualities of a Wagnerian Erda figure, as if arising ethereally from the Earth to propound her wisdom. But all is swept away by the shocking tumult of the fourth movement, confronting us again with those fundamental questions about life and death. Driven on by Nott, the orchestra respond with terrific virtuosity, particularly the percussion department. Off-stage front, extra horns and wind bands are exactly as heard from the auditorium, at varying distances and carrying acoustics from the hallways behind the stage. A profound sense of tension is built up, with great surges of sound (and a truly magnificent tam-tam) which keep receding, like those always unattainable summits which Mahler used to walk over while composing on his holidays.

At last we reach the final pages; the pitch-perfect soprano voice of Anne Schwanewilms emerges steadily from the muted chorus to soar gloriously above the gathering tsunami of sound. Time seems to stand still as the carefully guided build-up to the peroration unfolds.The Bamberger Symphoniker Chorus may not be a huge group, but their contribution is tonally rich, especially in the multi-part divided choruses, and their fervent dedication to the work is palpable. There is no difficulty in feeling when the full organ arrives with its deep pedals and sizzling upper work reeds, or when the extra brass are added, bells-up. The blazing detail and sheer dynamic range of the last pages is staggering; the whole auditorium space is acoustically excited as the building adds its own contribution to the glorious climax, compellingly enveloping listeners lucky enough to be listening in multichannel.

To my ears, this is the best recorded and projected performance of all my Resurrection discs; the Finale's pay-off is so inspiring that I was left awestruck and elated. However loud it is played there is no distortion, hardness or congestion at peak levels. The balance appears to be that set by the conductor with minimal interference by the engineer - there is just the right amount of deep bass from string basses, tubas, contras and bass drum but they never obtrude; cymbals hiss, piccolos pierce, L-R divided strings aid clarity of polyphony but the sonic image is fully coherent and never phasey.

Tudor's Resurrection Symphony is a most welcome addition to my select collection of this particular symphony. I found the performance and recording both superlative. It left a deep emotional impression on me. I'm off to play it again.

Copyright © 2010 John Miller and

Review by JohnProffitt April 19, 2010 (9 of 14 found this review helpful)
Performance:   Sonics:  
A terrific performance and recording. Nott takes a dramatic, no nonsense approach to Mahler 2, and this public performance is captured in excellent, wide-range 5.0 surround -- there is no distracting noise that I can detect from the audience. Strings are full and resonant; the brass massive but not overpowering; the percussion truly spectacular in unrestrained dynamic range; the chorus is recorded somewhat forward in perspective, and can be clearly understood -- a good thing; and the two soloists -- unfamiliar to me -- are superb.

For my taste, this performance is as good as any of my previous favorites (live or studio) in Mahler 2, and better than most; and the recording is likewise Spitzenklasse.

A triumph for Nott, Mahler and Tudor Records.

Was this review helpful to you?  yes | no

Review by wilbur December 29, 2012 (6 of 8 found this review helpful)
Performance:   Sonics:  
I just bought this the other day after resisting for a while. I have 1,3,4,5,7 and 9 in Nott's series, and I think it is a truly wonderful achievement overall. I personally think 7 and 9 are the best performances I have heard.
So, what of this Resurrection? Overall I am sad to say its really a bit disappointing. The first movement goes pretty well, but neither of the Landler/Scherzos really convince. Both are slow and plod quite a bit: too rhythmically intransigent. Thus they miss the whimsical aspect that makes this music so amazing. "Urlicht" is OK. The mezzo is OK, but again, it never really gets off the ground. After the symphony was over I put on a bit of Maureen Forester's performance with Slatkin (still my favourite Mahler 2) and it was a totally different, intimate, magical world. The finale also doesn't quite catch fire: the final apotheosis seems to come up suddenly and is over before one really realises (and its not a tempo issue).
Various other reviewers of other volumes in this series have harped on about the Bamberg orchestra not being a truly top class one. I think that is rubbish. This orchestra is absolutely first class. In this performance, however (which, again, is live)I don't believe they are quite up to the standard they have set previously. The cellos, in particular, so often showcased in this symphony, seem to lack weight and fire (when required). It all sounds a bit genteel. Then we get to the last movement and there are some real problems. The sustained trumpet high C (admittedly cruel) costs the player audible effort to initiate, and it is agonisingly under pitch after that. The tuning in the long ruminating dialogue between the offstage brass and onstage high wind is also pretty ordinary. Again, its a live performance, but these things really grate, with this listener at least.
So, while there are some nice things, I don't think I will be returning to this very often. The sound is very good mostly, although it sounds a little congested in the upper midrange sometimes, more so than other recordings in this series.

Was this review helpful to you?  yes | no