add to wish list | library


1 of 1 recommend this,
would you recommend it?

yes | no

Support this site by purchasing from these vendors using the paid links below. As an Amazon Associate SA-CD.net earns from qualifying purchases.
 
amazon.ca
amazon.co.uk
amazon.com
amazon.de
 
amazon.fr
amazon.it
 
jpc

Discussion: Rarities. Chamber Musical - Brogli-Sacher

Posts: 3

Post by Windsurfer March 24, 2013 (1 of 3)
So, in quest of the Franck, I did buy it. I wish I had not read the review however.

Maybe someday Praga, BIS, Audite, Coviello or somebody with a good string quartet and pianist will give us a superb recording of the Franck Piano Quintet.

Post by nucaleena March 24, 2013 (2 of 3)
And maybe the two Dvorak Piano Quintets espec op. 81, the Mozart and Beethoven piano & wind quintets plus the less well known Atterberg quintet, the early Bartok Q5, the Bax, the two Berwald Q5s, Bloch, Boccherini (several), Cadman, Elgar, Enescu, Faure, Gubaidulina, Hadley, Hahn, Hummel, Korngold, Piston, Rubinstein, Saint Saens, Spohr, Widor, Wolf-Ferrari amd many others I'm sure.

Of these, and including the Franck, the Dvorak op. 81,the Elgar and the two by Faure plus the Mozart and Beethoven quintets for piano and wind are widely acknowledged as masterpieces (and I have a soft sport for the Boccherini quintets as well).

I'd hoped that Praga would have given us some of these by now, especially the Dvorak but also the French composers on my list, given Praga's French ownership. Chandos for Elgar and Bax??? Bis for Berwald?

And as for piano quartets (again incl Dvorak's pair) and trios still languishing on RB only, and other chamber works like the Brahms string sextets and quintets....at the rate we've progressed in the past ten years it'll be at least a decade before we hear them as they're meant to be heard, in HD.

Don't get me wrong, I'm grateful for what we've got but, like Edward G Robinson's character in "Key Largo", I want more.

Post by Windsurfer March 25, 2013 (3 of 3)
nucaleena said:

Of these, and including the Franck, the Dvorak op. 81,the Elgar and the two by Faure plus the Mozart and Beethoven quintets for piano and wind are widely acknowledged as masterpieces (and I have a soft sport for the Boccherini quintets as well).

I'd hoped that Praga would have given us some of these by now, especially the Dvorak but also the French composers on my list, given Praga's French ownership. Chandos for Elgar and Bax??? Bis for Berwald?

And as for piano quartets (again incl Dvorak's pair) and trios still languishing on RB only, and other chamber works like the Brahms string sextets and quintets....at the rate we've progressed in the past ten years it'll be at least a decade before we hear them as they're meant to be heard, in HD.

Don't get me wrong, I'm grateful for what we've got but, like Edward G Robinson's character in "Key Largo", I want more.

you want more ? Me Too!

Closed