add to wish list | library


11 of 20 recommend this,
would you recommend it?

yes | no

 
 
Label:
  LSO Live - http://www.lso.co.uk/
Serial:
  LSO0576
Title:
  Walton: Symphony No. 1 - Davis
Description:
  Walton: Symphony No. 1

London Symphony Orchestra
Sir Colin Davis (conductor)
Track listing:
 
Genre:
  Classical - Orchestral
Content:
  Stereo/Multichannel
Media:
  Hybrid
Recording type:
  DSD
Recording info:
 

join discussion | delete from library | delete recommendation | report errors
 
Related titles: 15 show all


 
Reviews: 2
add review

Site review by Polly Nomial May 12, 2006
Performance:   Sonics:    
This is the latest LSO Live release and I have to commend them on the improved sound that they have achieved in this issue - it is still not of Pentatone standard but compared to discs of a year or so ago, it is far better and much easier on the ears.

Anyway, to the central issue: what is the performance like? Well, it's curiously deficient - the LSO play magnificently and the vocalising of Sir Colin Davis is largely inaudible. However, no matter how committed the playing, one senses that Davis is trying just a bit too hard to find depth and emotions that just aren't present in the score (I got too much of "let's try to make the opening sound like Sibelius" rather than accepting Walton having his own 'voice'). This is a great shame because it stops the feeling of sheer elation and vibrancy in the faster music that other interpretors have bought to this score. However, the Andante con malinconia is very nicely done indeed but it is a shame that this movement sticks out like the one finger surrounded by three sore thumbs!

Ultimately, when judged against the finest recordings available, the playing has a few too many rough edges to make this a library choice and there a few slightly sour notes from the trumpets at the works' climaxes. Though the recording is far better than some from the Barbican, the sound is still pretty dry. Not bad but not great.

(Purchased)

Copyright © 2006 John Broggio and SA-CD.net

Review by Edvin June 9, 2006 (4 of 7 found this review helpful)
Performance:   Sonics:  
There are times when I want to write a review saying: Oh how I love this music, and this recording made me love it even more. Fine.

My first Walton one was the Sargent. It came with the approval of the composer for some strange reason. I loved it dearly and it was not until I heard Previn/LSO a few years later that I really grasped the width of the symphony. Many have come since then and I still admire the Thomson and Haitink. The former beacuse of its sheer brutality and the latter for its breadth and vision.

Enter Sir Colin Davis, somewhere in between. This is a great performance in every way, but this symphony is so great that a definitive version will never surface. As in every masterwork there are as many views and opinions as interpretations. My first thought when this sacd arrived was that if a conductor can do Berlioz and Tippett better than anyone else, Walton should be pretty good also. And it is, it is pretty damn good.

This evening I listened to it a fifth time and I turned the volume up really high. The opening is jagged and nervous, full of expectations. The movement proper is very dramatic and at times very sensous. Those Waltonian lines are gorgeous and the lead up to the final pages are so dramatic I felt a sweat coming. No rest for the wicked, a malicious scherzo with horn playing of the highest order. Those trills! Virtuoso playing from the LSO and I almost felt as if I were present at a motor race. Or at least the Barbican.

A melancholy andante, well, I didn´t much care for the tone of the flute at the beginning. Apart from that the movement evolves gracefully and there is so much poetry in this music. When I listened to this I was reminded of why George Szell liked Walton so much, he really was a genuine composer. The ending so Sibelian with those C-sharps from no 4. Sometimes people put forth that the finale is a late addition and that it doesn´t sound as a natural finale. Rubbish I say. This is a grand finale and if Elgar had heard it he would have been proud of the inheratage. Everyone rises to the occasion and delivers a splendid conclusion.

I don´t know if Sir Colin have performed this symphony many times or not and there are minor details that could be improved. They are indeed minor and the total verdict is YES.

The sound is close and incredibly dynamic. I love it to bits because this is what a symphony orchestra sound like in the flesh. Can we now have a Tippett second symphony from these forces please. By the way, no gruntings from Davis. This is a gem.

Was this review helpful to you?  yes | no

 
Works: 1  

William Walton - Symphony No. 1