add to wish list | library

1 of 2 recommend this,
would you recommend it?

yes | no

Support this site by purchasing from these vendors using the paid links below. As an Amazon Associate earns from qualifying purchases.
  Musicaphon -
  M 56909
  Poetry. Epic. Program - Brogli-Sacher
  Richard Strauss: Don Juan, Till Eulenspegel, Igor Stavinsky: Le Sacre du Printemps

Philharmonisches Orchester der Hansestadt Lübeck
Roman Brogli-Sacher (conductor)
Track listing:
  Classical - Orchestral
Recording type:
Recording info:
  Recorded: Strauss 8-9 July 2007, Stravinsky 8-9 June 2008 Löbeck

read discussion | delete from library | delete recommendation | report errors
Related titles: 3

Reviews: 1

Review by Jonalogic April 20, 2013 (5 of 6 found this review helpful)
Performance:   Sonics:
Heavens, but this is a frustrating disc, and a challenging one to review. If I had to summarise, I would say that this is a (mostly) superb, natural-sounding recording of an under-powered orchestra playing orchestral showpieces in a fine acoustic. And there is also a notable 'gotcha' I must mention...

You want more?

Sonics first. If you have read my review of the Honegger symphonies on the Musicaphon label, and Geohominid's illuminating review of the Strauss 'Also Sprach Zarathustra', then you will know what to expect. This Cybele-engineered disc sounds quite superb. Key to this is an essentially unfussy, and un-mucked around recording which presents a real orchestra, playing in a real acoustic, in a startlingly natural way. Everything is unforced, but properly in its place. Dynamics are notably fluid, expanding into climaxes in a surprisingly realistic way. It's approach is rather like older Chandos recordings, but (I suspect) with the DSD recording allowing greater see-through.

So, if you like crushing boom 'n tizz, Telarc's bass drums or surgically dissected and re-assembled recordings where every instrument gleams, then this is not for you. Avoid!

Needless to say, however, I just love this sound to bits. It's subtle, natural and may just be the best engineered of the 30 or so recordings of the Rite I have on vinyl, CD and SACD. But...

The music. Oh dear, I've written over 200 words, and have yet to mention that the opaque disc name amply disguises the fact that the pieces on offer are the Richard Strauss tone poems 'Don Juan' and 'Til Eulenspiegel', together with the Stravinsky 'Rite of Spring'. All are spectacular orchestral showpieces, just begging for big-band fireworks.

They don't materialise, regretfully. To paraphrase the immortal Morecombe and Wise/Andre Previn sketch of yore, the Lubeck orchetra does at least play the right notes, AND in the right order. But they are massively underpowered to deliver them at full strength. As a result, the Don's frenetic swagger and ultimate disintegration fails to excite, Til's sly wit becomes po-faced and...

A digression. I remember, in the good old days (ha!) only crack orchestras and conductors, drilled to within an inch of their lives, were allowed anywhere near the 'Rite'. Now everyone and his dog plays it - and twice on Sundays. Just because orchestras nowadays CAN play the Rite without major catastrophes, however, doesn't mean that they SHOULD. The result is the sort of underwhelming performance we get here. Technically correct but uninvolving and - yes - even plodding.

And the big gotcha? It's the bass drum, dammit. Needless to say, the hanging scene from 'Til' and much of the 'Rite' depend on a meaty, extended bass thump from this big-boy. For much of the recording, however, it seems to have wandered off-stage for a swift pint. I kept wondering if they could only afford a teeny Fisher-Price Bass drum; alternatively, the percussionist responsible had forgotten to turn up. My last possible explanation was that the conductor had developed an aversion to the instrument after being attacked as a youngster by a rogue one.

Strangely, it finally turns up in the last sacrificial dance of the 'Rite'. But by then it's just too late.

Was this review helpful to you?  yes | no

Works: 3  

Richard Strauss - Don Juan, TrV 156 Op. 20
Richard Strauss - Till Eulenspiegels lustige Streiche (Till Eulenspiegel's Merry Pranks), TrV 171 Op. 28
Igor Stravinsky - Le sacre du printemps (Rite of Spring) (1913, rev. 1947/67)