Review by Blu Falcon June 4, 2011 (7 of 7 found this review helpful)
|
Performance: Sonics: |
Not sure if this will be a fair review. I was only a passive JT listener until I got this SACD. My new appreciation for all things Carole King led me to explore more of James Taylor's recordings. With that said, I can't compare this to the original LP, cassette, 8 track, reel to reel, CD, mp3... so sorry. What I will say is that the music on this album is nothing short of phenomenal, and I can't believe I've waited this long to give JT a spin. Nice mellow easy listening tunes perfect for a Sunday morning listening session, or unwind with your liquor of choice after a long day at the workplace. I suppose as we grow older our musical taste develop into something a bit more refined and not so angst ridden. I've been very pleased with all the MoFi SACDs I've acquired so far, and this one does not disappoint in the least. Without a frame of reference to go by in terms of previous versions of this album, I can only say that MFSL mastering duo of Shawn R. Britton and Rob LoVerde has once again given us a reference quality mastering worthy of the MoFi label. Nothing comes off as ear-bleeding shrill or lifeless and dull, but rather that rich, creamy, full signature sound we've now come to expect from MoFi SACD releases. Instruments sound natural, not overbearing but perhaps just a tad laid back on a few tracks, allowing one to fully take in JT's soothing vocals. I use Yamaha source components for SACD playback, which are just a tad on the warm side of neutral to my ears. The overall presentation of this recording is very mellow and warm, and you tend to forget that you're listening to a digital transfer rather than an analog format. Amazing. You know it's an excellent mastering job when you pay no attention to the trivial technical details, but become totally immersed in the music instead. This release follows the current MFSL trend of mini-LP style packaging with the disc housed in a scratch resistant sleeve, further protected by a hard paper outer sleeve, which provides a detailed description of the proprietary GAIN2 mastering system. There are no additional booklet with liner notes. The mini gatefold fits right in with other current MoFi SACD releases. Overall, this SACD is well worth the cash whether you're a hardcore or even a passive fan. While I can't say with absolute certainty that this is THE definitive version, I would be surprised if there is another version out there that is sonically superior. Buy with confidence.
|
Was this review helpful to you?
yes |
no
|
|
Review by Tingman July 5, 2011 (5 of 5 found this review helpful)
|
Performance: Sonics: |
Recently I had some negative things to say about a different MFSL SACD, and I was concerned that they might no longer be the company that produced the great vinyl that I purchased in the late '70's - early 80's. With JT I must give credit where it is due - this release sounds wonderful.
As a collection of songs it may be Taylor's best (although I have a soft spot for Mudslide Slim), and many of the songs here have remained staples of his live act since the LP's release. Thus, if you have a cursory interest in the music of James Taylor, this is a great purchase - if you already know his music, then you know how good this music is.
While this title was released in multichannel once upon a time, that version is long out of print ( and can command ridiculous prices). With that said, when I get a two channel SACD that sounds this good, I really don't bemoan the lack of a rear channel too much. This SACD sounds wonderful. Taylor's vocals ring true, and the presence the engineers have created is reference-quality.
I am pleased to sing the praises of MFSL in bringing JT to SACD, and highly recommend this title.
|
Was this review helpful to you?
yes |
no
|
|