add to wish list | library

23 of 28 recommend this,
would you recommend it?

yes | no

Support this site by purchasing from these vendors using the links provided below. As an Amazon Associate earns from qualifying purchases.
  Channel Classics -
  CCS SA 24507
  Richard Strauss: Josephs Legende - Fischer
  Richard Strauss: Josephs Legende

Budapest Festival Orchestra
Ivan Fischer (conductor)
Track listing:
  Classical - Orchestral
Recording type:
Recording info:

read discussion | delete from library | delete recommendation | report errors
Related titles: 22 show all

Reviews: 3

Site review by Castor April 13, 2007
Performance:   Sonics:  
The text for this review has been moved to the new site. You can read it here:

Review by jlaurson October 10, 2007 (10 of 10 found this review helpful)
Performance:   Sonics:  
Iván Fischer, Richard Strauss, Josephs Legende (from

In his introduction to his latest recording, Iván Fischer points out that the score of Richard Strauss’ Josephs Legende is frightfully difficult. I’ve no doubt that’s true – especially when no player in an orchestra is likely to have seen, much less played, a single note of it before. Fischer goes on to suggest that Josephs Legende, which he calls beautiful (yes!), rich (yes!), and especially lyrical (yes!), should be considered among Strauss’ best compositions.


If “best” is supposed to denote anything meaningful at all, then Josephs Legende is not likely included. But that’s not to say that it isn’t a wonderful work. There are not that many clunkers in Strauss’ output to begin with, and Josephs Legende is certainly a (much) better work than Friedenstag, Die Schweigsame Frau, Die Göttin im Putzzimmer (“The Goddess in the Boudoir”), Festmusik for the 2600th Anniversary of Japan, or even the Sinfonia Domestica. Nor is it to say that it wouldn’t be enjoyed more than some “better” works. I.e. more than Elektra by those who like their Strauss lyrical. Or better than those who would love Die Frau ohne Schatten were it not for want of time.

Josephs Legende is a Sergei Diaghilev commission for his Ballets Russe, based on a libretto concocted by Hugo von Hofmannsthal and the colorful Count Harry Kessler, that jack of all trades, diplomat, and friend of seemingly every important or famous personality of the early 20th century. Strauss accepted the idea – but the religious story didn’t sit right with him. More labor than love might have gone into Josephs Legende, even as Strauss made sure that the music displaced any all-too mystical or religious aspects of the story with earthy eroticism. The result is a work that, composed on Elektra and Salome’s heels, is less ambitious than either, shorter, less varied, but not much less enticing. If Elektra has curdled blood flowing in its veins, and Salome a sweet poison, Josephs Legende is fueled with Viennese Mélange .

You can hear ideas in it that foreshadow Die Frau ohne Schatten. An unkind, but hardly inaccurate, description of Josephs Legende would be that of a test-run for the latter opera. Set to a story of Hofmannsthal that was much more to the liking of Strauss.

The ballet, when it was finally finished and performed under Strauss’ own direction on May 14th, 1914 in Paris, was a success. Even if Vaslav Nijinsky, for whom this “least danceable music possible” was created, was no longer part of the production after he had hastily married Romola De Pulszky, which caused the outraged (and jealous) Diaghilev to fire him on the spot. Michail Fokine (choreography) and Léonide Massine (as Joseph) substituted. With over 130 performances since, the ballet was hardly a failure. But even though it was resuscitated after World War I, it seemed to symbolically draw the curtain on the 19th century (to paraphrase Michael Kennedy) and has spent most of its time since on the sidelines of Strauss’ musical output.

A shame for this lusty and lush hour of opera-meets-dance-meets-tone poem that sends Straussian climaxes through the over-sized orchestra by the minute. Even vigorous repeat listening have not yet turned me off Josephs Legende. I’ve been enjoying, alternatingly, the Giuseppe Sinopoli / Dresden Staatskapelle recording (DG; available as an “Arkiv-CD” in the United States) and the new SACD recording of Iván Fischer and his Budapest Festival Orchestra (Channel Classics).

Either one of these – and the third available recording on EMI with Rudolf Kempe’s complete orchestral Strauss, also with the Staatskapelle – are excellent. The Staatskapelle has Strauss in its blood and Sinopoli sweeps through the score in broad grandeur, with sumptuous expanse and gravitas. Fischer, meanwhile, is a touch fleeter, lighter. More tone-poem with the former, more a hint of ballet with the latter. If Fischer could be pointed to as being more delicate it’s not to say that Sinopoli muddles anything. Both bring out all the voices wonderfully… in an orchestra among the biggest that Strauss ever summoned. (Which is saying something for both, the conductors and the size of the orchestra.)

This Strauss beckons to be enjoyed on disc – lest you happen to stop by in Hamburg where the Staatsoper will actually put on the ballet with John Neumeier’s choreography.

Was this review helpful to you?  yes | no

Review by ruxtonvet June 12, 2012 (6 of 14 found this review helpful)
Performance:   Sonics:  
I purchased this based on the reviews and the fact that I basically like Richard Strauss. This is definitely not first rate Strauss. There is little to distinguish the beginning from the middle and end of the piece. There is good reason that the piece has fallen out of favor. What was especially surprising was the sound quality. I had to listen to the opening three times to try and understand what I was hearing. The best word I can use is distortion. Maybe something in my system was the culprit and not the recording, but I have 276 SACDs and I have never heard this type of distortion before from a SACD. There is an odd flatness to the sound throughout the disc although the distortion is only in the opening notes. I listen in two channel. I would certainly pass on this one.

Was this review helpful to you?  yes | no

Works: 1  

Richard Strauss - Josephs-Legende, TrV 231 Op. 63